Electric vs Acoustic Guitar: Which Should You Choose?

One of the first decisions every new guitarist faces is whether to start on an electric or an acoustic guitar. Both are great instruments, and neither is the “right” answer for everyone. The best choice depends on the music you love, where you’ll practice and how much gear you want to deal with. Here’s how they compare.

How each type makes its sound

An acoustic guitar has a hollow wooden body that amplifies the vibration of the strings. You can pick it up and play anywhere, with no power or extra equipment. Steel-string acoustics are bright and loud; classical guitars use nylon strings and have a softer, warmer sound.

An electric guitar usually has a solid or semi-hollow body and is quiet on its own. Magnetic pickups turn the string vibrations into an electrical signal, which is sent through a cable to an amplifier. The amp, and any effects pedals, shape the final sound, from clean and glassy to heavily distorted.

Playability

Electric guitars are generally easier on the hands. They use lighter strings, have slimmer necks and usually have the strings set lower to the fretboard, so you need less pressure to play notes and chords. Bending strings is easier, too.

Acoustic guitars have heavier strings with more tension, and the bodies are larger. Beginners often find their fingertips sore for the first few weeks while calluses build up. On the plus side, many players feel that learning on an acoustic builds finger strength that makes electric playing feel easy later.

Either way, a good setup makes a huge difference. A poorly adjusted guitar of either type will be hard to play.

Which suits your music?

• Acoustic fits folk, country, singer-songwriter, campfire strumming, fingerstyle and unplugged pop.
• Classical suits classical, flamenco, bossa nova and fingerpicking.
• Electric fits rock, blues, metal, funk, indie and most jazz.

Many styles work on both, but if your favorite songs are built around distorted riffs or expressive solos, an electric will keep you inspired. If you mainly want to accompany your singing, an acoustic is hard to beat.

Cost and extra gear

An acoustic guitar is a complete instrument. Beyond a tuner, picks and a case, you’re ready to go.

An electric guitar needs an amp and a cable at minimum, which adds to the starting cost. Small practice amps or headphone amps are affordable options, and many beginners eventually add effects pedals. That extra gear is part of the fun for many players, but it is worth budgeting for.

Noise and practice space

Acoustic guitars can be fairly loud, which may be a concern in apartments or shared homes. Electric guitars are quiet unplugged, and you can practice with headphones through a headphone amp, an amp with a headphone jack or an audio interface, which makes late-night practice easy.

Portability

Acoustics are self-contained, so you can take them to a park, a friend’s house or on a trip with nothing else to carry. Electrics are often lighter to carry in a gig bag, but you’ll need to bring or borrow an amp to be heard.

Which is easier to learn?

Electric guitars are physically easier for most beginners, but motivation matters more than anything. The guitar you want to pick up every day is the one you’ll learn fastest on. If you’re torn, think about the songs you most want to play first.

Acoustic-electric guitars

An acoustic-electric is an acoustic guitar with a built-in pickup and preamp. It sounds and plays like an acoustic, but you can plug it into an amp or PA system for performing. It is a good option if you plan to play at open mics or with a band, but it won’t give you the distorted electric guitar sound.

Can you switch later?

Yes. Skills transfer well between the two. Chords, scales and rhythm are the same, and many players own both kinds. Starting on one doesn’t lock you in.

Quick comparison

• Easier on the fingers: electric
• Ready to play with no extra gear: acoustic
• Quiet practice with headphones: electric
• Best for singing along: acoustic
• Widest range of sounds: electric

Picking strings for each

Acoustic guitars use bronze or phosphor bronze strings, while electrics use nickel-plated or stainless steel strings that work with magnetic pickups. The two are not interchangeable. See our guide on how to choose guitar strings for gauges and materials.

Next steps

Once you’ve decided, our guide to the best guitars for beginners lists widely recommended starter models of each type, and our list of essential guitar accessories covers what else you’ll need.

Frequently asked questions

Is it bad to learn on an electric guitar first?

Not at all. Many great guitarists started on electric. It’s easier to play and may help you stick with practice.

Do I need lessons for either type?

Lessons help with technique and motivation, but many people learn successfully with online lessons, books and practice.

Is a classical guitar a good first guitar?

Yes, especially for children and for anyone interested in classical or fingerstyle music. Nylon strings are the gentlest on fingertips.

Heads up: NicheStuff is our own shop, so we earn from purchases made through these links.